Comcast trials Domain Helper service
The DNS hijacker is here to stay.
When Denver-based developer Brent Gartner returned home from vacation this week, he discovered that Comcast, his home ISP, was redirecting his mistyped urls to its very own ad-laden search pages. Earlier this month, the cable giant resurrected this age-old land-grab scheme in several US markets, including Colorado, with an eye on hijacking typos across the country.
Comcast does provide an opt-out. And Brent Gartner promptly did so. But the new scheme still boils his blood. “This pisses me off as it will surely break many web-serivces, spiders, and any client other than web browsers that use HTTP,” he tells The Reg. “It looks like a blatant attempt to steal revenue from competing services.”
As you might expect, Comcast doesn’t call its DNS hijacker a DNS hijacker. It prefers “Domain Helper service.”
“Despite the fact that web addresses are easier to remember than their IP address counterparts, sometimes you mistype an address,” reads a company blog post. “Normally, you then sit and wait for the Web browser to time out, then you receive an error message that the site does not exist, and then you have to retype the correct address.
“With the Domain Helper service we are testing now, we will instead help direct your Web browser to an easy-to-use page with suggestions and links to get you back on track. We also provide a seamless search experience on this page, which is powered by Yahoo!, so you can find relevant search information, or simply perform another search.”
Other markets can expect some hijacking in the near future. “The goal is to roll it out nationally when we’re done testing in these initial markets,” a company spokesman tells us.
Countless other ISPs have introduced similar schemes, including Charter, Cox, Earthlink, and Verizon. And some, including California-based ISP DSL Extreme, were forced to reverse themselves in the face of user complaints.
Famously, VeriSign once tried to hijack typos as a top-level domain operator. That didn’t work out.
Comcast has at least been open about the matter – while providing an opt-out.
The ISP does not prevent the use of the third-party DNS servers – though it was falsely accused of doing so earlier this year.
OpenDNS does this same type of DNS hijacking, so why is it ok for them? OpenDNS is a opt-in service, you don’t have to use it if you don’t want to. Comcast’s DNS servers come on every computer. That leaves your only option to be to change DNS servers once these changes go national.
